Voir le sujet précédentAller en basVoir le sujet suivant
ycombe
ycombe
Monarque

Survivorship Bias in Education Empty Survivorship Bias in Education

par ycombe Jeu 30 Juin 2016 - 19:13

An Interesting Example

During World War II, Abraham Wald worked for the New York company Statistical Research Group. The American military approached him with a problem. War planes were coming back from air battles covered in bullet holes, and the military was interested in protecting future planes by using minimal armour placement. The question was where to best place this armour so as to protect the planes and pilots. The bullet holes were roughly distributed as such:
Survivorship Bias in Education Untitled
Where would you choose to place the minimal armour?

If you said any section other than the engine section, then you would be absolutely… wrong. Wald’s explanation is as follows: the statistics that were presented were gathered from planes that had survived battle – the planes that didn’t survive battle were not included in the numbers. Thus, the planes that returned were not a random sample and conclusions could not be made by only reflecting on the surviving planes. Wald recommended adding armour to the sections of the plane that returned home relatively unscathed (here, the engine section) would be wise, as the surviving planes tell us the regions of the plane that can take damage and still return home safely.

Suggesting to give armour to regions of the plane that are damaged the most reflects a statistical bias known as survivorship bias.
Lire la suite:
https://bryanpenfound.wordpress.com/2016/06/23/survivorship-bias-in-education/

_________________
Assurbanipal: "Passant, mange, bois, divertis-toi ; tout le reste n’est rien".

Franck Ramus : "Les sciences de l'éducation à la française se font fort de produire un discours savant sur l'éducation, mais ce serait visiblement trop leur demander que de mettre leur discours à l'épreuve des faits".
fifi51
fifi51
Fidèle du forum

Survivorship Bias in Education Empty Re: Survivorship Bias in Education

par fifi51 Ven 1 Juil 2016 - 10:46
C'est un classique en statistique de s'interroger sur ce qu'on mesure réellement, mais il est vrai que le biais possible n'est pas toujours évident à discerner .

_________________
Oui, j'ai un clavier Fisher Price pour l'instant !
Voir le sujet précédentRevenir en hautVoir le sujet suivant
Permission de ce forum:
Vous ne pouvez pas répondre aux sujets dans ce forum